Skip to main content

Concert Reviews


2025

1 April
Die Winterreise


While waiting at the Barracks movie theatre for my friend Katalin, I leisurely picked up a March edition of Limelight Magazine when the headline "Winter is Coming" caught my attention. In an interview, Clive Paget discussed the visit to Australia by German baritone Matthias Goerne to perform Franz Schubert’s song cycle Die Winterreise


Matthias Goerne

The MSO program states that ‘A Winter’s Journey’ was: “Composed in the final year of Schubert’s life, this haunting song cycle ventures through a profoundly emotional winter landscape and draws listeners through expressive vocals intertwined with nuanced pianism.”

ABC’s Classics Mairi Nicolson notes that Matthias Goerne has sung Winterreise hundreds of times. To quote Goerne: "I would say it's [Winterreise] the most perfect kind of story. It's about a human being confronted with all the normal things we have to face in life: that we are disappointed; that we do not understand; that we are missing love. It's not complicated to listen to or understand. Even when the words are delivered in a very poetic language, people are into it very quickly.

This piece is so timeless, so uniquely connected with humans. Even 2,000 years ago it would be the right cycle, and I'm quite sure in 2,000 years people will listen to it." He adds: "A lot of classical music will disappear — but Schubert's Winterreise will not be one of those pieces."


I have the fondest memories of Die Winterreise since my stepfather was an opera singer and frequently sang this cycle to his accompaniment on the piano. I can still remember the words of many songs since some were very popular in my youth. My blood pressure rose ecstatically as I read Paget’s article about which Australian cities Matthias would honour with his visit.

No, Brisbane was not one of them. He was going to perform only in Adelaide, Sydney and Melbourne. At the time of my reading, Adelaide had already happened. That left Sydney and Melbourne. What to do. I wanted; no, I needed to see and hear Matthis Goerne. How often do you have the chance to enjoy Die Winterreise live in Australia? The more I thought about it, the more urgent my longing became.

Due to urgent appointments, we couldn’t do Sydney. That left Melbourne. Leaving the RNM* baffled by my swift actions, I booked performance tickets, flights, and accommodation for Melbourne the following week. I was flooded with the warmest memories of my stepfather singing Wilhelm Műller’s 24 poems, which Schubert immortalised with his compositions. This meant so much to me, bringing to life memories that I thought long buried.


On the day of our departure from Brisbane, we were humoured by the signage at Central Station, which left no doubt but was still puzzling as to where the lifts were. 

3 right, 1 left, which one??

Travelling on the air train, you have the luxury of being practically the only person on board. Where are all the people? I often wonder when returning from overseas or, as I was to find out, from Melbourne.

Melbourne does not have trains but buses that take you from the airport to the city. 

Mövenpick House opposite Central Station

From Central Station, we walked, guided by the RNM's sense of direction as a born and bred Melbournian, to our hotel next to the Big Bees, which are part of the Melbourne Skydeck building. 

View from our hotel

After checking in, freshening up and changing clothes, we meandered towards the Recital Hall.

I love the differing but harmonising architecture


Individuals moved in all directions, from work, to work, from lunch, to pre-dinner activities, or to the show. We found an outdoor table. Our telephonic ordering process was such that the kind waiter rushed to offer assistance. Ah, the joy of modern living with technical gadgetry.

The moment of our entry into the hallowed space arrived.


We found our seats on the upper level of the magnificently wooden panelled Hall—and when I say panelled, that includes the ceiling. The centre stage featured a stunning grand piano. Here, it might be an appropriate time to talk about the performers.


Matthias Goerne recorded the Winterreise four times, the last of which is available on DVD. He loves to challenge himself by working with different pianists in recitals. My hero, Alfred Brendel, do read my close encounter with him in Schwarzenberg under ‘Travel’, famously asked him if he could work with him when he was very young: ''Until I heard Herr Goerne, nobody since Fischer-Dieskau had inspired me to go back to Lieder.''

During his Australian tour, Goerne was accompanied by the Russian pianist Daniil Trifonov. 



Reliving the many listening moments in my youth to my stepfather’s singing was magic. While Goerne’s mimic demeanour was a hitherto unknown style to me, after all, the last time I heard the Winterreise was in my youth in Germany, I did enjoy his singing, if only for my mind to be reminiscent of times long gone. At times, I felt Trifonov’s dominance a tad obtrusive. Despite Stewart Kelly’s review in 'Classic Melbourne':

“The bottom line: it was an evening of masterful interpretation from a singer who knows the music intimately but whose voice is not quite what it was. He was joined by a pianist of no doubt astonishing ability who is perhaps still more at home in front of a symphony orchestra than alongside a singer, and who is more naturally aligned with Rachmaninov than Schubert.

An evening with this extraordinary music is never wasted and it was heartening to see a near full Elisabeth Murdoch Hall for the timeless art of Lieder and the timeless messages of Müller’s poems.”

I enjoyed the performance and the whole experience immensely, a view shared by Mairi Nicolson: “His voice is surely one of the most beautiful of our time, strong and tender with a velvety overlay.”  


After the recital, we were charmed by nighttime Melbourne while searching for a coffee. 


The next day, we were rewarded by the delights offered at the Acland Street precinct. YUM! It's just as well we don’t live in Melbourne. 

The beach is very close; we got there by tram. I often hear that the weather in Melbourne is dreadful; well, the sun was shining for us. So much so that I absolutely fell in love with this city and wanted to relocate, an impulse halted by the RNMs rationality. 

to the east

to the west

Luna Park is best

Back to our hotel and the 88-floor ride to the Skydeck

view from below

view from above

towards the mountains

towards the sea

Back in Brisbane town with memories of yet another fantastic adventure in this life of mine.


*RNM - retired nursery man


2022

Guitar Extravaganza - Queensland Conservatorium
5 October 2022

almost all of the 16 performers on stage

It’s been a while since we last saw a live performance. Yesterday evening was special; it was Geoff’s birthday. 

After a lecture about Queensland artist Joe Furlonger at the Gallery of Modern Art in the morning -


and a delectable lunch at Stanton’s overlooking Queen Street Mall, what better way to celebrate that special day than a Guitar Extravaganza? Where? At the Queensland Conservatorium.

This annual concert is probably a little kept secret and worth strumming its tune. According to Head of Classical Guitar, Karin Schaupp, the guitar department has grown immensely over the last few years. Credit, no doubt, to her directorship. 

The program opened with the Open Con Guitar Ensemble under the smooth direction of Joel Woods, warming up the theatre with Rumba Flamenca, Sakura Variations and Ballade. Next, the Open Con Guitar Ensemble joined the Riverside Guitar Ensemble to play Karl Jenkins’s Palladio

Classical pieces by Beethoven and Brahms formed part of the repertoire. Apart from the two Ensembles, the Jacaranda Guitar Quartet delighted with a performance of Brahms’s Hungarian Dance No. 5 and contemporary Duncan Gardiner’s In Paradiso Midar compositions. Karin Schaupp teamed up with her childhood mentor Janet Agostino rendering a treat of virtuosity.


Karin Schaupp and the Ensembles

After the interval, an arrangement of Flamenco, Deep Purple and hot classical guitar medley concluded this most enjoyable evening. A note to self – watch out for next year’s Extravaganza. 



Nemanja Radulovic and the Queensland Symphony Orchestra


A few weeks ago we went to the QSO to hear Tchaikovsky and Beethoven under the programmed direction of Alondra de la Parra. We were informed just before the opening Sinfonia that the conductor had taken ill one hour ago, she was on the way to the hospital as the announcement was made. I think the whole audience took one deep breath. 
Nemanja Radulovic

To the credit of all performers and organisers, a replacement conductor Dane Lam, who was in town to direct Opera Queensland's Orpheus and Eurydice, was found. This necessitated a change in the programme and instead of Ibarra Groth's Sinfonia No. 2, we heard the overture to Gluck's opera, which Dane was performing with the QSO for Opera Qld.

Violinist Nemanja Radulovic, I can only describe this as catapulted, onto the stage for the second piece. Apart from his somewhat unusual attire, white jacket over black tights and white tutu-like skirt, he gave a spellbinding rendition of Tchaikovsky's Concerto in D for Violin and Orchestra. Nemanja was the soloist as well as the conductor of the QSO. He played, he conducted, he faced the audience, he faced the orchestra, his solo violin developed passionately from its original theme into 'rhapsodic excitement' (Programme notes). What a treat, in all our concert attendances we have never seen or heard anything as mesmerising as this. And while we hope that Alondra had a good recovery, we are happy not to have missed this electrifying performance. 

After interval we settled back into listening to Beethoven's Symphony No. 6 in F, Pastorale. And as the title suggests we meandered through a pastoral setting incorporating an awakening of nature, a merry rural mood, a summer's thunderstorm and the rejoice after it. A fitting ending to a wonderful concert performance.


The Queensland Choir at Twelfth Night Theatre - A Tribute to Marjorie Johnstone 

On Sunday, 15 September, I went with my friend Sue to the Twelfth Night Theatre. The Queensland Choir, under the baton of Kevin Power and founded in 1872, ably performed excerpts from classical composers like Mozart, Bach, Brahms, Strauss, Rossini, Vivaldi and Verdi during the first Act. In the second Act songs from popular musicals like Cats, Jesus Christ Superstar, Evita, Starlight Express and Phantom of the Opera roused the full house out of their seats. 



This event was staged as a fitting tribute to Marjorie Johnstone, who ran The Johnstone Gallery with her husband Brian between 1952 and 1972. They exhibited the works of great artists like Margaret Olley, Grace Cossington Smith, Sidney Nolan, Charles Blackman, Arthur Boyd, Ray Crooke, Lawrence Daws and many more.


The Johnstone's involvement with theatre resulted in the building of the present day Twelfth Night Theatre complex. When its doors opened in 1971 the Theatre Club hit the news with its '12 to 12 licence' under which, for the first time, women were - can you believe it? - able to order and pay for a drink 'and still feel feminine' (The Johnstone Gallery Archive: Scrapbook 1970: RBHARC 7/1/13, p.148). This trailblazing act was taken up by the current theatre owner, Gail Wiltshire, who in 1977 faced the enormous challenge of restoring a theatre that had fallen into disrepair. Apart from their passion of loving the theatre, Gail and Marjorie became great friends. In a moving theatrical tribute Gail, with panache, allowed the audience to share her deep affection for Marjorie.
Photographer unknown
Brian and Marjorie Johnstone with Lindy, c.1960
RBHARC 7/1/4 13143, p.38, The Johnstone Gallery Archive,
Australian Library of Art, State Library of Queensland

https://art-museum.uq.edu.au/whats/past-exhibitions/2014/remembering-brian-and-marjorie-johnstones-galleries

Shikara Ringdahl gave a spine tingling performance of Don't cry for me Argentina. Standing on the backstage staircase enhanced the dramatic effect. Greg Moore and Jason Barry-Smith sang with their usual polished professionalism. The audience loved it and seemed to leave on a higher note!

Sue enjoyed this Phantom of the Opera presentation more than one she had attended a little while ago. What a wonderful way to spend a Sunday afternoon.


Masterclass with Paul Lewis at The University of Queensland's School of Music

On Tuesday, 10 September, Geoff and I attended this remarkable event. To music lovers the internationally acclaimed pianist Paul Lewis needs no introduction; he is renowned for his cycles of core piano works by Beethoven and Schubert and is the recipient of numerous worldwide awards. And, if your read my Travel snippet about Schwarzenberg 06/2017 and my infatuation with Alfred Brendel, Paul studied privately with Alfred Brendel. Yes, I am a tad excited. So there we were, being included in Paul giving a Masterclass.  

Each student (female and male), performed their chosen piece by Chopin and Schumann respectively. Whether is was Paul demonstrating how loosening up the wrist perfects the performance or other suggestions on how to improve the students' musical rendition, he generously gave wisdom and feedback. It was a wonderful experience for students and audience alike. 

When asked by an audience member which of Paul's advice the students would prioritise, he humbly replied 'none', but that they would reflect about their own performance. After the event we were treated to drinks and nibbles. Since we had tickets for Paul playing on Thursday, we were truly primed for that concert:

Romance and Revolution, Paul Lewis plays Beethoven with the Queensland Symphony Orchestra at the Concert Hall, QPAC

On 12 September, Paul played Beethoven's Concerto No. 3 in C minor for Piano and Orchestra, Op. 37. Robert Gibson writes in the Programme Notes that: 'The solo piano is a crucial player in the drama, creating much of the momentum through brilliant passages (forceful scales, decisive octaves, dazzling ornamentation) but also by pulling back and lowering the temperature as required.' What else can I add? It was simply fabulous. And, Mr Brendel, I blame your influence on acquiring a new hero of musicianship. 


The Great Symphony - Simone Young Returns at QPAC


Saturday, 20 July Geoff and I went to a QSO concert. Under the Baton of Simone Young the programme featured the Australian premiere of Brett Dean's Notturno inquieto, Béla Bartók's Viola Concerto, and Franz Schubert's Symphony No. 9 in C Major. The first two pieces focus on the viola section, in fact, German-based Nils
Mőnkemeyer was the soloist for the Bartók piece.

We listened to the pre-concert talk, which is always very informative and provides valuable insights. For example, Dean is the only composer to have witnessed the performance of his own composition; Bartók and Schubert died before the premiere of their works. The speaker also pointed out that the programme encompassed the works of a 19th, 20th, and 21st century composer. This comparison raised our curiosity. 

The concert was well attended. Before the concert hall doors open, I always enjoy sitting into foyer perusing the, at times, lavish outfits of concert goers. These attires can be, not totally Viennese 19th century ball gowns, but imaginatively close to it. I dressed modestly in black. Once seated inside the concert hall, it is interesting to see the musicians file on to the stage as they prepare for their performance. There were quite a few children scattered amongst the audience. I admire parents who introduce their children to classical music at an early age by bringing them along.


Brett’s work contained sounds that seemed quite unusual and I envisaged the first hesitant emergence of nocturnal animals that eventually formed into an army sweeping the landscape. In between I thought I detected a faint didgeridoo sound, but I need to hear it again to be certain. It was great to witness the Australian premiere here in Brisbane.

Mőnkemeyer mastered the rhythmic challenges of Bartók's viola concerto with ease and virtuosity. I look forward to seeing and hearing more of this young violist.

After the interval we listened to the four movements of Schubert's powerful and dramatic Great C Major Symphony. The work's themes convey to me tragedy and yet a triumphant optimism that leaves me with lingering pondering about what life is all about.

It was such a treat to see Simone Young conducting. She delivers with dynamism and yet ultra-sensitivity, swaying like a graceful dancer, bending her knees, silently stamping her feet for emphasis, leading the orchestra into tune and rhythm. She is fantastic, no wonder she was, apart from having received many awards, voted Conductor of the Year (2006) by Opernwelt. The Queensland Symphony Orchestra responded to her direction and gave a wonderful rendition on the night.


If you missed this concert, you can listen to it on ABC Classic on 30 July at 8 pm and on 6 November at 7 pm. I know what I will do that Tuesday night!